Summary of Citizen’s Survey
Friday, January 23rd, 2009Many thanks to all you great people in Kidder County who took the time to fill out a survey to help us write a business plan for Golden Manor, in the event we are granted our nursing beds back. The results of the survey are listed below.
In early December, the Citizens to Save Golden Manor conducted a random survey to determine the preferences of Kidder County residents, in regards to nursing home care. A total of 363 adults responded with 56% of the respondents being 64 years or younger while 37% were between the ages of 65 and 84 years of age. The survey was conducted before or after church services and all churches in Kidder County, with the exception of the Lutheran Church in Tuttle which declined, participated along with one church in Burleigh County, the Lutheran Church in Driscoll. The results of the survey are as fallows.
When asked if you are no longer able to care for yourself and would require 24 hour nursing care where would you want to reside, 82% of the respondents would want to reside at Golden Manor if given a choice as compared to 5% who would prefer the Bismarck/Mandan area, while another 11% would prefer moving out of the area completely to be closer to children or other family members. 2% of the respondents chose not to respond to the question.
When asked whether the respondents had long-term care insurance, 22% indicated that they had insurance as opposed to 77% who indicated they did not have long-term care insurance . 1% did not respond to the question. About 1/4 to 1/3 of the respondents who said they had long-term care insurance indicated they did not know if their policy included coverage for assisted-living or home-care. In addition, of those who said they had long-term coverage, only 77% indicated that their policy included nursing home care. Thus, one must conclude that possibly there was some confusion between long-term care and life insurance of other insurance policies since normally nursing home care is covered , but assisted-living and home care coverage may or may not be covered. The older the policy the more likely assisted-living and home care are not covered.
When asked which factor you consider most important when choosing a nursing care-facility, 59% of the respondents indicated that being close to family was the most important factor while 37% indicated that receiving quality care was the most important factor. only 3% of the respondents indicated that having private room was the most important factor and less than 1% indicated that a variety of activities or beautiful new surroundings were the most important factor. It should be noted that 36 of the 363 respondents checked more than one factor and of those 36 who checked more than one factor, 5 checked all factors listed even though they were asked to check only one. There fore their responses are not included in the above percentages. However, if all their responses are included the data would indicate that being close to family (224 of the 363 respondents) and receiving quality care (155 of the 363) were the two most important factors. A variety of activities and a private room was indicated by only 19 and 22 of the respondents respectively while 9 of the 363 respondents checked beautiful new surroundings as a factor.
Based on the results of this rando survey, one must begin questioning the wisdom ofmoving nursing homes to urban areas when the survey clearly indicates that the respondents thought being close to family was the most important factor when deciding where they would want to reside if given a choice. Also, who benefits the most from building nursing facilities that emphasize private rooms when only 22 of the 363 respondents considered having a private room as an important factor? Finally, what actions should be taken so that the residents of Kidder County and the surrounding areas have a choice as to where they want to reside and how can their preferences be relayed to those making decisions about the future of the nursing home industry in North Dakota?